PromptAI
Appearance
Research

Paper deconstruction

The questions a good journal-club reviewer would ask, applied to any paper abstract or text.

Deconstruct this paper:

1. Claim: what exactly do the authors claim, in one sentence?
2. Evidence: what did they actually measure/build, and does it support the claim?
3. Limits: what populations/conditions/scales does the evidence NOT cover?
4. Alternatives: what other explanations fit the same results?
5. Verdict: how much should this update my beliefs, on a scale from "noise" to "field-changing", and why?

Paper:
[PASTE ABSTRACT OR TEXT]
Open in ChatGPT Claude

Works with Claude · ChatGPT · Gemini — replace the [bracketed] parts with your own details, keep the structure.

Want a new tested prompt every week? The PromptAI briefing delivers the AI story that matters, the paper everyone's citing and a prompt worth stealing — subscribe free →

More prompts like this